Seems like your theory needs to explain why there wasn’t a whole lot more agriculture or why the myths led to agriculture such a small percentage of the time
Most sex doesn't result in conception, doesn't mean it's unrelated! More to the point, I'm open to fairly indirect explanations:
>Consider the mundane version of my model. About the same time as dogs spread the world over, mystery cults did as well, and these were a cultural stepping stone to agriculture.
Which you wouldn't expect to lead to agriculture every time, but still explains why agriculture popped up many places at roughly the same time
But we do rightfully seek an explanation for why sex results in conception only occasionally, which is what I sought. I may have misinterpreted how direct you thought the link (though consider generalizations such as "wherever the snake cult spread . . ."). We'd still like to know what was different about the very few places where ag did arise independently.
I'm curious about your claims about the timelines. I may have missed it but I don't recall seeing any references for the timeline of dog diffusion or how well it matches up with the spread of the "snake cult" or agriculture. Do you have any for that?
"Generously, one could say the authors simply don’t want to get out over their skis, but you just know that if they found a 12,000-year-old bullroarer in Australia they would be falling over themselves to demonstrate ritual continuity. The article would not be titled On the Pitfalls of Iconographic Interpretations of Aboriginal Art."
well spotted. This is also characterizes all of the writing about Bachofen's work: HOOOWWWWW could he possibly posit stuff about ancient Indo-Europe before writing, he was just a fantasist and a fool and a racist and an all-round baddie
Some Australian Aboriginal myth seems to have a basis in geological history from 35kya: WOOWWWW AMAZING YES GREAT STUFF TRUE FACTS HIGH FIVE
I asked one of the authors on the Gobekli Tepe bullroarer paper about continuity with Greece and they actually DM'd me saying it was a good question. Couldn't get much more out of them. Type of thing I'd like to discuss over a beer. They cite Zerries, one of the old diffusionists who said a Paleolithic cult spread from Europe to the rest of the world, so they know the implications of the debate.
I continue to be amazed at how strange Bachofen's work is, and yet he did call the men's rebellion the Dionysian age and talked about the role of mystery cults. Without ever meeting the Papuans who said the same more explicitly
I agree with you on the timing issue, the problem of “independent invention,” and the idea that cultural substrates travel farther than academics admit. But I’m thinking that rather than a cult, the emersion could have been the result of a coherence threshold. Once environmental stability, population density, and stored knowledge aligned, agriculture activated wherever that threshold was crossed. I admit that I'd like to think of myth as motivation, though!
Which is why I spent so much time giving examples of similarities that the threshold model would not predict. Why is the bullroarer associated with agriculture in cults from Greece to Namibia?
Your examples are great! The threshold model doesn’t predict the bullroarer itself, but rather the conditions under which a latent pattern activates. The similarities could be the fossil record of a shared substrate, but they could also be what happens when groups under the same stability‑density‑knowledge threshold reach for the same tools to manage ritual, coordination, and memory. In other words, the bullroarer might not be the cause of agriculture, but a recurring cultural solution that appears whenever that threshold is crossed. I’m not rejecting diffusion, just suggesting that coherence pressure might explain why certain motifs re‑emerge even without a single cult driving them. It's really interesting to think about though! I admit that it's a possibility.
The origins of agriculture seem mysterious because we (arguably until only recently) haven't possessed a fuller picture of developments leading us down the spectrum of agriculture. What we saw was an archaeological record where there doesn't seem to be an agriculture (characterized by hunting-gathering), followed by a period where agriculture is very much present (8000kyr-present). This is the same obstacle which faced Darwin in his examination of the shapes and forms of life, and spurred the theory of evolution. It was a paradigm shift which did away with the discrete categorization of kinds which held before.
The entire argument of an "agricultural revolution" is very last century and based on a concept as coined by V. Gordon Childe, who viewed the world through the lens of Marxism to explain what he saw as rapid changes in social organization.
What we know is that there was no rapid social re-organization; there was no abrupt shift into agriculture, there is no point in the timeline where it can be said human didn't cultivate, and when they began. What we know now does not presuppose there was anything unusual or sudden regarding agricultural development. In fact, human intentionality is not even needed for the process to unfold! Most agricultural developments happened entirely by accident, for example the emergence of tangerines, oranges, apples from chance hybridization between wild progenitors. The creation of wheat from repeated hybridizations of Levantine grasses, or maize and quinoa from repeated hybridizations among variously related wild crop ancestors of each.
This is a picture of population movements, dynamic connections between far flung places, and human-assisted plant and animal migrations co-occurring with trading networks and ecosystem engineering (such as cultural fire, repeated visitation of prime gathering or hunting grounds, etc.).
What the archaeological record tells us now is that the earliest traceable proto-agriculture goes back at least 50,000 years to the fynbos ecosystems of South Africa. Neanderthals and Denisovans appear to have practiced a form of proto-agriculture too circa 40,000 years ago. All the world's major domestication events took place thousands of years after cultivation of wild crops had already been in full swing. It was the pre-domestication cultivation which made all later developments possible and set the scene. It is possible proto-agriculture stretches back even further still, perhaps beyond 100kyr and to the beginnings of so-called "behavioral modernity"...
But the trouble is, you can't see this proto-agriculture as long as our language adheres to the binary yes/no of a so-called "agriculture revolution." It wasn't a revolution, it was an evolution. That's not semantics. It's a different paradigm.
I have written a piece on agricultural origins that you're welcome to check out -- it talks about a lot of these concepts.
>The entire argument of an "agricultural revolution" is very last century and based on a concept as coined by V. Gordon Childe, who viewed the world through the lens of Marxism to explain what he saw as rapid changes in social organization.
Yo zach that is not a productive appeal to authority / dig. Especially when you obfuscate what our disagreement may be, how we'd know who is right, etc.
>What we know is that there was no rapid social re-organization; there was no abrupt shift into agriculture, there is no point in the timeline where it can be said human didn't cultivate, and when they began.
And there's no fine line between colors on a rainbow, but alas, it's useful to talk about yellow and blue. My position is that what we call agriculture did not exist until about 12,000 years ago. This included sedantism, and relying on domesticated grains and animals for food. Aspects of this could have existed for a long time and be important to understand why the package came together. But that is not primarily what I am trying to explain. I am trying to explain why there was temporal alignment.
The problem with this line of thinking is that there were no "Agricultural revolutions." There was instead slow and steady evolution, with domestication events being long, protracted affairs interconnected across geographic scales for thousands of years before the domesticated forms arose.
As for the bullroarer cult, there are other explanations. It could be an outgrowth of the primal earth diver myths common around the world, especially in Eurasia. Said earth diver myths have probably be passed along for 100,000 years (read about the loss of the seventh sister of the Peliades 100kyr). Myths are also shaped by the forms and metaphors of the body. That separate cultures would independently create similar myths to explain their own origins and various natural phenomena is not at all surprising, nor does it suggest diffusionism for every similarity.
And of course, regardless of any particular explanations, correlation does not imply causation.
I'm not interested in semantic games about what constitutes a revolution. Even if a transition takes thousands of years, there is still a mystery of why it was aligned around the world and I am still putting forth an explanation that is better than independent invention:
"This is not to say that a prehistoric Triptolemus brought yams to New Guinea. Rather, the snake cult contained the kernel of agriculture. This could have been indirect, such as a social structure that made it easier for the tribe to plan their next season. It could be the idea of sedentism or a language with pronouns or matriarchy or patriarchy or better calendars or any number of things. The point is that the agricultural revolution in New Guinea is derivative of cultural developments in Eurasia."
As for your point about the earth diver myth, I address this at length, read the section around:
"There is a standard move for academics who find worldwide cultural similarities that can’t be explained by chance. Simply assert diffusion after Out of Africa is impossible, and that the root must therefore be in Africa more than 50,000 years ago. For example, folklorist d’Huy does this with the origins of the worldwide motif F-38:"
It's pure cope that Pleiades is 100,000 years old. A much more parsimonious model is that it entered Australia much later from Eurasia but the academics just assume that is impossible.
Ok I wrote you a reply but it somehow attached as a reply to Randy Garza and I'm not sure how to change it. I can't seem to edit nor copy the text to paste as a new message. My apologies.
Agriculture. I didn’t look into bullroarer. The evidence depends of the preservation of plant matter. Plant matter degrades. Finding newer stuff is expected. Losing older stuff is expected. Clusters like this are more easily explained by loss of records rather than proof of an event. Ohalo II is evidence for this because of its age and how exceptional its preservation conditions are.
This is similar to our dating of human civilization and writing is clustered. Problem is records made in wood and paper decay so the evidence is biased by what is preserved in more durable mediums like stone.
Seems like your theory needs to explain why there wasn’t a whole lot more agriculture or why the myths led to agriculture such a small percentage of the time
Why is that? The thing to explain is why there is no agriculture then a surprising amount of it?
You posit a direct causal link between x and y. So why is it most often the case that you get x and no y?
Most sex doesn't result in conception, doesn't mean it's unrelated! More to the point, I'm open to fairly indirect explanations:
>Consider the mundane version of my model. About the same time as dogs spread the world over, mystery cults did as well, and these were a cultural stepping stone to agriculture.
Which you wouldn't expect to lead to agriculture every time, but still explains why agriculture popped up many places at roughly the same time
But we do rightfully seek an explanation for why sex results in conception only occasionally, which is what I sought. I may have misinterpreted how direct you thought the link (though consider generalizations such as "wherever the snake cult spread . . ."). We'd still like to know what was different about the very few places where ag did arise independently.
I'm curious about your claims about the timelines. I may have missed it but I don't recall seeing any references for the timeline of dog diffusion or how well it matches up with the spread of the "snake cult" or agriculture. Do you have any for that?
fantastic read, intriguing stuff
Thanks!
"Generously, one could say the authors simply don’t want to get out over their skis, but you just know that if they found a 12,000-year-old bullroarer in Australia they would be falling over themselves to demonstrate ritual continuity. The article would not be titled On the Pitfalls of Iconographic Interpretations of Aboriginal Art."
well spotted. This is also characterizes all of the writing about Bachofen's work: HOOOWWWWW could he possibly posit stuff about ancient Indo-Europe before writing, he was just a fantasist and a fool and a racist and an all-round baddie
Some Australian Aboriginal myth seems to have a basis in geological history from 35kya: WOOWWWW AMAZING YES GREAT STUFF TRUE FACTS HIGH FIVE
I asked one of the authors on the Gobekli Tepe bullroarer paper about continuity with Greece and they actually DM'd me saying it was a good question. Couldn't get much more out of them. Type of thing I'd like to discuss over a beer. They cite Zerries, one of the old diffusionists who said a Paleolithic cult spread from Europe to the rest of the world, so they know the implications of the debate.
I continue to be amazed at how strange Bachofen's work is, and yet he did call the men's rebellion the Dionysian age and talked about the role of mystery cults. Without ever meeting the Papuans who said the same more explicitly
"This can only happen if human origins are a collective blind spot, a load-bearing taboo."
I agree with you on the timing issue, the problem of “independent invention,” and the idea that cultural substrates travel farther than academics admit. But I’m thinking that rather than a cult, the emersion could have been the result of a coherence threshold. Once environmental stability, population density, and stored knowledge aligned, agriculture activated wherever that threshold was crossed. I admit that I'd like to think of myth as motivation, though!
Which is why I spent so much time giving examples of similarities that the threshold model would not predict. Why is the bullroarer associated with agriculture in cults from Greece to Namibia?
Your examples are great! The threshold model doesn’t predict the bullroarer itself, but rather the conditions under which a latent pattern activates. The similarities could be the fossil record of a shared substrate, but they could also be what happens when groups under the same stability‑density‑knowledge threshold reach for the same tools to manage ritual, coordination, and memory. In other words, the bullroarer might not be the cause of agriculture, but a recurring cultural solution that appears whenever that threshold is crossed. I’m not rejecting diffusion, just suggesting that coherence pressure might explain why certain motifs re‑emerge even without a single cult driving them. It's really interesting to think about though! I admit that it's a possibility.
The origins of agriculture seem mysterious because we (arguably until only recently) haven't possessed a fuller picture of developments leading us down the spectrum of agriculture. What we saw was an archaeological record where there doesn't seem to be an agriculture (characterized by hunting-gathering), followed by a period where agriculture is very much present (8000kyr-present). This is the same obstacle which faced Darwin in his examination of the shapes and forms of life, and spurred the theory of evolution. It was a paradigm shift which did away with the discrete categorization of kinds which held before.
The entire argument of an "agricultural revolution" is very last century and based on a concept as coined by V. Gordon Childe, who viewed the world through the lens of Marxism to explain what he saw as rapid changes in social organization.
What we know is that there was no rapid social re-organization; there was no abrupt shift into agriculture, there is no point in the timeline where it can be said human didn't cultivate, and when they began. What we know now does not presuppose there was anything unusual or sudden regarding agricultural development. In fact, human intentionality is not even needed for the process to unfold! Most agricultural developments happened entirely by accident, for example the emergence of tangerines, oranges, apples from chance hybridization between wild progenitors. The creation of wheat from repeated hybridizations of Levantine grasses, or maize and quinoa from repeated hybridizations among variously related wild crop ancestors of each.
This is a picture of population movements, dynamic connections between far flung places, and human-assisted plant and animal migrations co-occurring with trading networks and ecosystem engineering (such as cultural fire, repeated visitation of prime gathering or hunting grounds, etc.).
What the archaeological record tells us now is that the earliest traceable proto-agriculture goes back at least 50,000 years to the fynbos ecosystems of South Africa. Neanderthals and Denisovans appear to have practiced a form of proto-agriculture too circa 40,000 years ago. All the world's major domestication events took place thousands of years after cultivation of wild crops had already been in full swing. It was the pre-domestication cultivation which made all later developments possible and set the scene. It is possible proto-agriculture stretches back even further still, perhaps beyond 100kyr and to the beginnings of so-called "behavioral modernity"...
But the trouble is, you can't see this proto-agriculture as long as our language adheres to the binary yes/no of a so-called "agriculture revolution." It wasn't a revolution, it was an evolution. That's not semantics. It's a different paradigm.
I have written a piece on agricultural origins that you're welcome to check out -- it talks about a lot of these concepts.
>The entire argument of an "agricultural revolution" is very last century and based on a concept as coined by V. Gordon Childe, who viewed the world through the lens of Marxism to explain what he saw as rapid changes in social organization.
Yo zach that is not a productive appeal to authority / dig. Especially when you obfuscate what our disagreement may be, how we'd know who is right, etc.
>What we know is that there was no rapid social re-organization; there was no abrupt shift into agriculture, there is no point in the timeline where it can be said human didn't cultivate, and when they began.
And there's no fine line between colors on a rainbow, but alas, it's useful to talk about yellow and blue. My position is that what we call agriculture did not exist until about 12,000 years ago. This included sedantism, and relying on domesticated grains and animals for food. Aspects of this could have existed for a long time and be important to understand why the package came together. But that is not primarily what I am trying to explain. I am trying to explain why there was temporal alignment.
The problem with this line of thinking is that there were no "Agricultural revolutions." There was instead slow and steady evolution, with domestication events being long, protracted affairs interconnected across geographic scales for thousands of years before the domesticated forms arose.
As for the bullroarer cult, there are other explanations. It could be an outgrowth of the primal earth diver myths common around the world, especially in Eurasia. Said earth diver myths have probably be passed along for 100,000 years (read about the loss of the seventh sister of the Peliades 100kyr). Myths are also shaped by the forms and metaphors of the body. That separate cultures would independently create similar myths to explain their own origins and various natural phenomena is not at all surprising, nor does it suggest diffusionism for every similarity.
And of course, regardless of any particular explanations, correlation does not imply causation.
I'm not interested in semantic games about what constitutes a revolution. Even if a transition takes thousands of years, there is still a mystery of why it was aligned around the world and I am still putting forth an explanation that is better than independent invention:
"This is not to say that a prehistoric Triptolemus brought yams to New Guinea. Rather, the snake cult contained the kernel of agriculture. This could have been indirect, such as a social structure that made it easier for the tribe to plan their next season. It could be the idea of sedentism or a language with pronouns or matriarchy or patriarchy or better calendars or any number of things. The point is that the agricultural revolution in New Guinea is derivative of cultural developments in Eurasia."
As for your point about the earth diver myth, I address this at length, read the section around:
"There is a standard move for academics who find worldwide cultural similarities that can’t be explained by chance. Simply assert diffusion after Out of Africa is impossible, and that the root must therefore be in Africa more than 50,000 years ago. For example, folklorist d’Huy does this with the origins of the worldwide motif F-38:"
It's pure cope that Pleiades is 100,000 years old. A much more parsimonious model is that it entered Australia much later from Eurasia but the academics just assume that is impossible.
Ok I wrote you a reply but it somehow attached as a reply to Randy Garza and I'm not sure how to change it. I can't seem to edit nor copy the text to paste as a new message. My apologies.
Meh, it’s instrument error. All of the evidence points to that time because that’s as long as the evidence can last.
The bullroarer or agriculture?
Agriculture. I didn’t look into bullroarer. The evidence depends of the preservation of plant matter. Plant matter degrades. Finding newer stuff is expected. Losing older stuff is expected. Clusters like this are more easily explained by loss of records rather than proof of an event. Ohalo II is evidence for this because of its age and how exceptional its preservation conditions are.
This is similar to our dating of human civilization and writing is clustered. Problem is records made in wood and paper decay so the evidence is biased by what is preserved in more durable mediums like stone.
Pottery preserves very well. Why don't we find it much earlier? Those civilizations didn't have pots?
https://substack.com/@vectors/note/c-330914375