Vectors of Mind
Vectors of Mind Podcast
Jonah Davids - Understanding Jordan Peterson
0:00
Current time: 0:00 / Total time: -1:25:01
-1:25:01

Jonah Davids - Understanding Jordan Peterson

Discussing the most influential psychologist of this generation
From Peterson’s We Who Wrestle With God book tour. He captions the picture: “What if you did nothing but aim high and look within yourself for everything that stopped you from moving forward?”

is a researcher and writer blogging about the science and politics of mental health at . In this episode, he joins me in dissecting the psychological and religious frameworks of Jordan Peterson, a figure we both consider to be the most influential psychologist of this century. The conversation probes Peterson’s academic origins, his appeal among young men, the evolution of his religious views, and the broader cultural implications of his work. We end by discussing whether Peterson’s prescriptions are enough for a meaningful life, and whether he provides us with the ammo to overcome nihilism. Ultimately, we come to see Peterson as an existentialist thinker who challenges his followers to overcome self-pity, despair, and depression through right action.

If you prefer the video version, that is available below:

Links

Highlights

Jordan Peterson is a polarizing figure, but Jonah and Andrew focus on less-discussed aspects of his legacy: his academic contributions, his unique approach to mythology and psychology, and the way his work connects to enduring questions about meaning, consciousness, and culture.

  • Peterson's Academic Origins:

    • Peterson’s early work as a clinical psychologist, focusing on addiction, aggression, and personality.

    • His time at Harvard and pioneering studies on the "higher-order factors" of personality—plasticity and stability.

  • Understanding Personality and Biology:

    • The role of dopamine and serotonin in shaping core personality dimensions.

    • Peterson’s emphasis on the biological underpinnings of personality traits like openness and conscientiousness.

  • Mythology, Religion, and Meaning:

    • Peterson’s interest in Jungian psychology and the collective unconscious.

    • Connections between ancient myths, modern psychology, and enduring human archetypes.

    • Specific discussions on the symbolism of snakes, religious myths, and their evolutionary significance.

  • Appeal to Young Men:

    • Peterson’s resonance with young men disillusioned by contemporary cultural narratives.

    • The controversial gender dynamics in his work and why these topics remain compelling.

  • Religious Evolution and Peterson’s Transformation:

    • The transition from Peterson’s early, nuanced biblical lectures to his more overtly political stances.

    • How audience capture and political pressures have shaped his public persona.


Timestamps

00:00–02:30 | Introductions and Light Banter

  • Andrew introduces Jonah as the creator of Mental Disorder, a Substack exploring mental health, culture, and skepticism.

  • Jonah highlights Andrew’s Vectors of Mind, which focuses on consciousness, anthropology, and religion.


02:31–07:00 | Jordan Peterson’s Background

  • Personal Connection:

    • Jonah shares a personal anecdote about growing up in Peterson’s neighborhood

  • Academic Foundations:

    • The hosts provide an overview of Peterson’s career as a clinical psychologist and Harvard professor.

    • Discussion of his research into addiction, aggression, and the Big Five personality traits.


07:01–14:00 | Peterson’s Academic Contributions

  • First Impressions:

    • Andrew reflects on discovering Peterson’s lecture series on the Big Five personality traits during his PhD research.

    • Jonah emphasizes Peterson’s ability to make complex psychological concepts accessible.

  • Higher-Order Personality Factors:

    • The hosts discuss Peterson’s research with Colin DeYoung on plasticity (openness and extraversion) and stability (conscientiousness and emotional regulation).

    • Connections between these traits and neurobiological systems like dopamine and serotonin.

  • Peterson as an Interviewer:

    • Andrew highlights Peterson’s skill in engaging with intellectuals like John Vervaeke, Iain McGilchrist, and Brian Muraresku, bridging psychology and mythology.


14:01–22:30 | Appeal to Young Men and Public Evolution

  • Cultural Impact:

    • Jonah and Andrew explore Peterson’s appeal to young men, attributing it to his essentialist approach to psychology, offering clarity in a time of cultural ambiguity.

    • Discussion of his focus on gender differences and biological determinants of behavior, which contrasts with socioculturally dominant frameworks.

  • Public Persona and Audience Capture:

    • The hosts analyze how Peterson’s audience expectations and political fame have influenced his evolution from academic to public intellectual.

    • Reflections on maintaining intellectual consistency under public scrutiny.


22:31–32:00 | Religion, Mythology, and Archetypes

  • Jungian Influence:

    • Peterson’s reliance on Carl Jung’s ideas of the collective unconscious and archetypes is examined, with examples from religious and mythological narratives.

    • Discussion of the psychological resonance of archetypes like the hero and the shadow.

  • Snake Symbolism and Evolutionary Psychology:

    • The significance of snake myths across cultures, from Genesis to global traditions, as metaphors for transformation and danger.

    • Tying mythological snake symbolism to evolutionary survival mechanisms.


32:01–40:00 | Myths: Universal or Diffused?

  • Jung vs. Campbell:

    • Jonah critiques Jung’s controversial stances and contextualizes his enduring popularity.

    • Andrew contrasts Jung’s archetypal theories with Joseph Campbell’s diffusionist perspective, which attributes similarities in myths to historical connections rather than universal structures.

  • The Role of Myths:

    • Debate over whether myths are psychologically universal or shaped by cultural diffusion.

    • Examples include creation myths and their function in exploring existential questions.


40:01–55:00 | Myths in Modern Media

  • Disney and Modern Archetypes:

    • Peterson’s comparative analysis of Disney and Grimm tales is explored, connecting them to ancient archetypes like the hero’s journey.

    • The hosts discuss Peterson’s ability to link modern storytelling to universal moral lessons.

  • Peterson’s Depth in Mythology:

    • Andrew and Jonah highlight Peterson’s detailed approach to mythology, often surpassing traditional biblical scholars in connecting psychological and cultural insights.


55:01–1:20:00 | Existentialism, Meaning, and Religion

  • Existentialism and Action:

    • Peterson’s framing as an existentialist thinker is discussed, with a focus on responsibility and action to combat nihilism.

    • The metaphor of “clean your room” as a call to address personal chaos as a first step toward broader meaning.

  • Religion as a Cultural Construct:

    • Exploration of Peterson’s religious views, framing God as both a psychological archetype and a cultural reality.

    • Discussion of how myths, like Genesis, capture humanity’s transition to self-awareness and grapple with existential alienation.


1:20:01–1:24:00 | Closing Reflections

  • Final Thoughts:

    • Jonah and Andrew reflect on Peterson’s dual legacy as a psychologist and public intellectual, acknowledging his polarizing impact.

    • Both express admiration for his interdisciplinary approach to understanding psychology, mythology, and culture.

  • Call to Action:

    • Encouragement for listeners to explore Peterson’s academic work and public lectures beyond his political persona.

Discussion about this podcast